Saturday, June 7, 2008

Round and Round: Columbus Circle

I was hauling an overloaded, suburban suitcase around Columbus Circle tonight and lo I see that the Museum of Art and Design (formerly Huntington Hartford's Gallery of Modern Art, a.k.a. 2 Columbus Circle, designed by Edward Durrell Stone and opened in 1964) was just a pane of glass and a coat of paint away from being finished. I was vaguely aware of the renovation by Allied Works and the losing crusade of any number of architectural middle and heavy-weights; I had been inconvenienced by that veil of scaffolding at least a few times in the past few years, but usually while I was focused either on that very Contextual Time Warner center or disappearing into the nature machine (i.e. Central Park). Tonight I got a real good look at the thing, and hardly noticed Time Warner at all (which I must confess here could barely keep my attention on the first visit). The facelift maintains the overall bulk of Stone's original extrusion. It looks great from the park and is decently scaled at the street level but I cannot advise looking up when passing by. Terra Cotta just doesn't look as good as it sounds, as I think the NY Times building has dully shown us all (even here in Brooklyn), and it certainly doesn't glow like those renderings (which seem more Nelson-Atkins that Modern Monolith on 59th). Furthermore, the monolithic, column-like nature of Stone's original design, which justified the unrelenting blank thrust if not necessarily excusing it, is lost in those snaking little windows which bring in some token sunlight. Looks to me like I'm going to get distracted by the park in those galleries, as the sunlight pours in just like it always does through thin little windows. Unfortunately, it looks like the new stair added in the renovation only connects the ground and second floor, and there is no interior realization of the promised sectional quality of the new facade. Lollipop or no, at least Stone didn't bait much beyond a sandwich behind that mask, which was the truth after all (praise be to an honest high Modernist).
The new facade is subsumed by the centrifugal pull of Columbus Circle, seemingly ripping apart at the seams. The activation of the facade brings the movement of the circle into the museum but at the cost of sacrificing that form. Stone's design unapologetically demanded that a circle remain a circle, really screaming it, as each of the old edge buildings had been gradually replaced by unsympathetic, unthoughtful buildings between and after the war(s) (especially the dumb bulk of its longtime neighbor the coliseum). Now its gone full circle; Time Warner is so into everything around it, and so wants to complete that circle, that a great deal of the pressure to hold down that form has been lifted from the AWA project. But Stone's was the circle, for 40 years, it made promised the messianic return of the circle, finally made flesh with SOM's monstrous background building that, suprisingly, actually does disappear from time to time (that is from the adjacent sidewalk, its contextual gestures at an urban scale are a whole different story). AWA's building gives up too much to Time Warner, which should be allowed to disappear as it wants to. Its a nice little wrapper and makes a great little drawing, but Stone's building was more sure of its own identity and could demand very boldly, albeit muted, what it wanted the city to be. Time Warner does this too, with a lot less subtlety, and at a global scale, but AWA seems to have leaked out a bit too much testosterone thorugh those little snaky windows.

No comments: